Every time the matter of garbage and bad governance comes up in our meetings, there is often the common comment that the
- ‘Citizens are to blame also’ or that
- ‘We have no ‘civic sense’,
- ‘We must not ask of the Government but must also do it ourselves’
On the face of it statements such as these sound reasonable and create a sense of temporary guilt and shame in the mind of the citizen and taxpayer. This type of discussion in public meetings usually ends the discussion with people simply feeling helpless as if they are no good.
Over the years this thinking has been reinforced by the State Administration and the officers as it suits them to shift the moral blame on residents for their own administrative incompetence and corruption.
Recently in a posh area of south Delhi, no less than the Commissioner of SDMC, an I.A. S officer, made a ‘surprise visit’. A day before this ‘Surprise’ visit many encroachments were temporarily removed. During the course of his visit the Commissioner noted, that residents had thrown kabaad in their back lanes and covered their drains leaving them difficult to clean. The Commissioner pointed out that residents were responsible for the problem and should introspect, & the suitably embarrassed the RWA wrote a note chastising the members that they must themselves ‘introspect’ on this
The situation remains the same. The encroachments are back, the back lanes remain dirty
On similar complaints, the Municipal councillor landed up with a whole team, touting ‘swachh bharat’ abhiyan as motivator, joined by party colleagues and cleaning staff. The whole lot including the Councillor started sweeping. Many Residents were all excited and started clapping. This was a major photo opportunity; the photo etc. was shared in whatsapp groups. At the end of all this tomfoolery, things remain the same
This is an example of how misled we are and how much it suits the officers and the politicians to perpetuate this thinking. It also shows that a combination of ignorance and laziness can keep even educated residents trapped in the same place.
This is important to understand, that ordinarily most people are law abiding but as a corrupt and lazy administration allows a few people to get away, more and more people take to breaking the law.
Please do not believe that residents in other countries are better human beings, but please believe that other countries punish law breakers and there Civic responsibility becomes reward able
Let us have a look by way of a table of what is happening and how we are misled into believing that are bad citizens, when in reality our officers a lazy and inefficient.
The distinction marked below can be applied to almost all areas of public administration
|Wrong Way- Delhi will remain a Filthy city||Right Way- Delhi will be a world Class city|
|SDMC Commissioner lecturing that Drains should not be covered||The Commissioner ordering immediate demolition/or penalties as per law and ordered an inquiry upon his officers for letting this happen|
|This not lack of Civic Sense||This is illegal|
|SDMC Commissioner lecturing that Kabaad should not be thrown in the back lanes
This not about lack of Civic Sense
|The Commissioner ordering fines and penalizing the builders as well as residents for violating the law and relevant provisions of the DMC act
This is about punishment for illegal activity
|The Municipal councillor, no matter how excitable and sycophantic he is, is not meant to begin municipal work himself
|The job of the councillor is to take civic problems to the corporation and get the Departments to act. He is not a Govt officer (even if he likes to think so) and does not have to perform Municipal roles designated for Municipal officers or staff|
|Councillor Sweeping back lanes are an aberration & example of very bad Governance should not be applauded by the public and there is nothing good about this activity to be shared on whatsapp. This public behaviour is harming the public
|Public should have criticized him for failing to get the Government to work and not take the Voter for a ride by doing childish stunts. The public should have demanded that he ensure MCD action. This behaviour helps the public|
|This pattern of behaviour will result in remaining in garbage and filth, broken roads and encroachment. This is how our ‘Administration’ and misguided residents behaves and we remain a backward city
|This is how Administration in USA, UK, France Tokyo, and Hong Kong would have behaved and that is why they are advanced Cities. This is how their officers behave and their residents demand for being taxpayers.|
|Officers will be paid for sitting in office and making money out of corruption &Indian taxpayer will be fooled continuously & will be blamed for not having civic sense. This wrong attitude shown above will ensure that Delhi will be a filthy city||Delhi will be a clean city, The Tax payer would be rewarded and provided with services, the officers will have to work for their salary, & corruption will come down. Delhi will be a world class city|